Camera phones: are the megapixel wars over at last?
Posted 8th March 2010 at 12:54pm by Joe Minihane
Just over a year ago, Sony Ericsson upped the ante and unleashed the Sony Ericsson Idou. The 12 megapixel-packing camera phone, which became known as the Sony Ericsson Satio, was the latest attempt to prove to punters that simply pumping up the pixels meant your mobile’s camera was better than your best mate’s.
Fast forward 12 months and things couldn’t be more different. Sony Ericsson’s new range unveiled at Mobile World Congress has peeled back the megapixel count to a more reasonable five, as found in the new Xperia X10 Mini and Vivaz Pro too. So, why the change of heart?

Officially, Sony Ericsson says there hasn’t been one. “Sony Ericsson is focused on delivering a balanced and innovative portfolio of products aimed at specific sectors of the market,” said a spokesman when we asked if the age of the mighty megapixel mobile was over. “Recently announced products such as the X10 family and Vivaz focus on key functionality, such as HD recording and unique user interface, whilst delivering the best spec available that suits the design of the handset.”
But in reality, there has been a sea change. The Satio has been plagued with problems. Away from the nasty niggles with software, the camera produced noisy shots which just couldn’t measure up to previous winning efforts like the 8 megapixel Sony Ericsson C905. Also, as punters want phones that can do everything decently rather than one thing incredibly, adding extra megapixels just doesn’t cut it.
Sony Ericsson isn’t alone in doing this. Samsung has taken things down a notch and hasn’t taken the opportunity (yet), to take things up to 15 megapixels, as many mobile watchers suggested they might last year. Nokia, which in recent years has hung back and let Samsung and Sony Ericsson fight it out with each other in the camera space, has also resisted the urge to make sensors larger.
Nokia’s Damian Dinning thinks the truce in the megapixel march isn’t simply down to consumers gagging for all-round smartphone powerhouses. “In the early days of mobile camera development, image quality improvements were most significant by simply increasing sensor resolution,” he says. “However, there is a point where the resolution of the sensor extends beyond the resolving capability of the optics.”
In fact, camera phones with optical zooms (as opposed to digital), have yet to leave the confines of the Far East, where a Samsung model was first spotted last September. Until such a time as they do break out of those markets, the focus is clearly shifting to capable cams which can capture decent shots of your pals which you can shovel onto Facebook or associate with contacts as part of the raft of new social networking skins.
Mr Dinning echoes this view. “It is essential that Nokia considers the real world performance of the camera, as well as the need to remain competitive in a highly competitive market. Nokia’s priority in this regard is firmly weighted more to real-world performance than simply specifications,” he says.
It’s pleasing to hear. But the question is, will the megapixel wars start in earnest once we get used to this generation of best-ever smarties? “We will continue to bring new and innovative devices to market but we cannot comment on future specifications,” says Mr Dinning of Nokia’s plans.
Likewise, Sony Ericsson cannot comment. As smartphones remain focused on web-based functionality, it looks like we’ll be left waiting for a truly killer cameraphone to appear in 2010. If you want cracking shots, best pack your compact.
4 Comments
-
Sofa Loafer, 8th March 2010.
I guess the thing is that as far as the man in the street is concerned more megapixels means better pictures. That's what he's been led to believe anyway.
Reply -
Chez, 15th March 2010.
All those megapixels are difficult to use. Ebay needs far less and do you really want to see every zit and blocked pore on your mates?
Reply
The next big thing is OLED screens using less power, if you ask me. -
Grem, 31st March 2010.
I have a Satio and it's the best fone I've ever owned. Had no problems whatsoever with it. The camera takes brill pics and my only complaint about it is that the music player sounds tinny. Other than that this is a great fone.
Reply -
Toni, 2nd May 2010.
I have a good reflex cam (Canon) that I use and it takes great photos. It's not necessary for a mobile phone to have a high-end camera. A cell phone needs a camera for "emergencies only" and it should be about 3 to 5 megapixels. Any more makes no sense.
Reply
Add your comment
-
Costs & tariffs
-
Extras
-
Handsets
- Acer E120 1 Articles
- Acer E130 1 Articles
- Acer F1 1 Articles
- Acer Liquid e 2 Articles
- Acer neoTouch P400 1 Articles
- Acer Stream 3 Articles
- BlackBerry… 3 Articles
- BlackBerry 9360 Tour 2 Articles
- BlackBerry 9800 8 Articles
- BlackBerry Bold 9700 5 Articles
- BlackBerry Curve 8520 4 Articles
- BlackBerry Curve 8900 4 Articles
- BlackBerry Dakota 2 Articles
- BlackBerry Pearl 8120 3 Articles
- BlackBerry Storm 2 7 Articles
- BlackBerry Storm 3 5 Articles
- BlackBerry Torch 7 Articles
- BlackBerry Tour 9650 2 Articles
- Bluebird Bip-6000 1 Articles
- Creative Zii Trinity 1 Articles
- Dell Mini 3i 2 Articles
- Dell Mini 5 1 Articles
- Dell Streak 3 Articles
- Dell Thunder 1 Articles
- Google Nexus One 54 Articles
- Haier H7 1 Articles
- HTC Aria 1 Articles
- HTC Bravo 1 Articles
- HTC Click 1 Articles
- HTC Desire 35 Articles
- HTC Desire HD 2 Articles
- HTC Dragon 1 Articles
- HTC Evo 4G 4 Articles
- HTC Gold 1 Articles
- HTC HD2 14 Articles
- HTC HD3 1 Articles
- HTC HD7 1 Articles
- HTC Hero 28 Articles
- HTC Incredible 4 Articles
- HTC Legend 10 Articles
- HTC Leo 3 Articles
- HTC Magic 5 Articles
- HTC Mega 1 Articles
- HTC Mondrian 3 Articles
- HTC Obsession 1 Articles
- HTC Pro3 1 Articles
- HTC Scorpion 1 Articles
- HTC Smart 4 Articles
- HTC Supersonic 1 Articles
- HTC Tattoo 7 Articles
- HTC Touch2 1 Articles
- HTC Wildfire 7 Articles
- ICD Vega 1 Articles
- Inabrics H1 1 Articles
- INQ Chat 1 Articles
- INQ Mini 1 Articles
- iPhone 523 Articles
- iPhone 3GS 417 Articles
- iPhone 4 284 Articles
- Land Rover S1 1 Articles
- Lenovo Lephone 1 Articles
- LG Arena Max 2 Articles
- LG BL40 Chocolate 4 Articles
- LG Chocolate BL20 1 Articles
- LG Cookie 1 Articles
- LG Cookie 3G 1 Articles
- LG Cookie Fresh 3 Articles
- LG Cookie GS290 1 Articles
- LG Cookie GT350 1 Articles
- LG Cookie Plus GS500 1 Articles
- LG Cookie Style 1 Articles
- LG Etna KS360 2 Articles
- LG eXpo 1 Articles
- LG GD910 1 Articles
- LG GT500 Puccini 1 Articles
- LG GT540 2 Articles
- LG GT540 Swift 1 Articles
- LG GW520 1 Articles
- LG GW620 3 Articles
- LG GW910 1 Articles
- LG GW990 3 Articles
- LG Louvre 1 Articles
- LG LU2300 2 Articles
- LG Mini GD880 2 Articles
- LG Optimus 7 E900 1 Articles
- LG Optimus GT540 2 Articles
- LG Pop 510 3 Articles
- LG Town GT350 1 Articles
- LG Viewty GW300 1 Articles
- Microsoft Kin One 4 Articles
- Microsoft Kin Two 4 Articles
- Motorola Defy 0 Articles
- Motorola Devour 2 Articles
- Motorola Dext 6 Articles
- Motorola Droid 6 Articles
- Motorola Flipout 1 Articles
- Motorola i1 3 Articles
- Motorola Milestone 11 Articles
- Motorola… 6 Articles
- Motorola Morrisson 3 Articles
- Motorola Motoroi 2 Articles
- Motorola Quench 1 Articles
- Motorola Zeppelin 1 Articles
- Nokia 2710… 1 Articles
- Nokia 3720 2 Articles
- Nokia 5230 3 Articles
- Nokia 5235 1 Articles
- Nokia 5250 1 Articles
- Nokia 5530 XpressMusic 1 Articles
- Nokia 5800 Comes… 2 Articles
- Nokia 5800… 1 Articles
- Nokia 6700 Slide 1 Articles
- Nokia 7230 1 Articles
- Nokia 7705 Twist 1 Articles
- Nokia C2 1 Articles
- Nokia C3 4 Articles
- Nokia C5 2 Articles
- Nokia C6 2 Articles
- Nokia E5 1 Articles
- Nokia E52 1 Articles
- Nokia E55 1 Articles
- Nokia E66 1 Articles
- Nokia E7 1 Articles
- Nokia E71 1 Articles
- Nokia E72 7 Articles
- Nokia N8 29 Articles
- Nokia N86 2 Articles
- Nokia N87 1 Articles
- Nokia N9 3 Articles
- Nokia N900 31 Articles
- Nokia N920 1 Articles
- Nokia N97 10 Articles
- Nokia N97 Mini 3 Articles
- Nokia N98 1 Articles
- Nokia X3 3 Articles
- Nokia X5 1 Articles
- Nokia X6 9 Articles
- Palm Pixi 12 Articles
- Palm Pixi Plus 7 Articles
- Palm Pre 39 Articles
- Palm Pre Plus 9 Articles
- Puma phone 1 Articles
- Samsung Armani 2 B7260 1 Articles
- Samsung Armani OLED 2 Articles
- Samsung Bigfoot 1 Articles
- Samsung Blue… 1 Articles
- Samsung Cetus 1 Articles
- Samsung Galaxy 13 Articles
- Samsung Galaxy 2 4 Articles
- Samsung Galaxy… 4 Articles
- Samsung Galaxy Q 1 Articles
- Samsung Galaxy S 16 Articles
- Samsung Galaxy Tab 8 Articles
- Samsung Genio Slide 1 Articles
- Samsung Genio Touch 1 Articles
- Samsung Halo 1 Articles
- Samsung i8000 Omnia 2 1 Articles
- Samsung Jet 2 Articles
- Samsung Jet Ultra 1 Articles
- Samsung M100S 1 Articles
- Samsung M8910 Pixon 12 1 Articles
- Samsung Omnia HD i8910 2 Articles
- Samsung Omnia II 3 Articles
- Samsung S5600 Blade 2 Articles
- Samsung S9110… 1 Articles
- Samsung SCH-W800 1 Articles
- Samsung SCH-W960 1 Articles
- Samsung Tocco Lite 1 Articles
- Samsung Wave 10 Articles
- Samsung Wave 2 2 Articles
- Seal Cell 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Aino 2 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Aspen 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson… 2 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Elm 2 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Faith 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Jalou 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Kurara 5 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Naite 2 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Pureness 4 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Rachael 2 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Satio 8 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Spiro 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson T715 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Vivaz 7 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Vivaz Pro 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson W995 0 Articles
- Sony Ericsson… 4 Articles
- Sony Ericsson… 11 Articles
- Sony Ericsson… 4 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Xperia X2 14 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Xperia X3 9 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Xperia X8 2 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Yendo 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson Zylo 1 Articles
- Sony… 1 Articles
- sWaP Watch Phone 1 Articles
- T-Mobile G2 Touch 3 Articles
- T-Mobile myTouch 3G 1 Articles
- T-Mobile Pulse 2 Articles
- Toshiba K01 1 Articles
- Toshiba TG01 3 Articles
- Toshiba TG02 1 Articles
- Vodafone 360 Samsung H1 1 Articles
- W Phonewatch 1 Articles
-
Industry news
-
Manufacturers
- 3 6 Articles
- Acer 11 Articles
- Apple 659 Articles
- Archos 1 Articles
- BenQ 1 Articles
- BlackBerry 165 Articles
- Dell 16 Articles
- Google 146 Articles
- Haier 1 Articles
- HTC 200 Articles
- Huawei 3 Articles
- INQ 2 Articles
- LG 117 Articles
- Microsoft 47 Articles
- Motorola 77 Articles
- Nokia 358 Articles
- Palm 80 Articles
- Samsung 137 Articles
- Sonim 1 Articles
- Sony Ericsson 131 Articles
- sWaP 1 Articles
- Toshiba 4 Articles
-
Mobile phones
- Android mobile phones 522 Articles
- Bluetooth mobile phones 5 Articles
- Bold mobile phones 8 Articles
- Business mobile phones 79 Articles
- Camera mobile phones 74 Articles
- Clamshell phones 5 Articles
- Concept mobile phones 29 Articles
- Cookie mobile phones 1 Articles
- Cool mobile phones 2 Articles
- Curve mobile phones 8 Articles
- Cybershot mobile phones 3 Articles
- Dual SIM phones 1 Articles
- ESeries mobile phones 2 Articles
- Facebook mobile phones 37 Articles
- Flip mobile phones 4 Articles
- Galaxy mobile phones 32 Articles
- Genio mobile phones 2 Articles
- GPS mobile phones 17 Articles
- Green mobile phones 21 Articles
- Internet mobile phones 7 Articles
- Keyboard mobile phones 111 Articles
- Music phones 57 Articles
- New mobile phones 299 Articles
- NSeries mobile phones 41 Articles
- Pay as you go… 8 Articles
- Pink mobile phones 4 Articles
- Purple mobile phones 1 Articles
- Retro mobile phones 3 Articles
- Skype mobile phones 8 Articles
- Slide mobile phones 24 Articles
- Small mobile phones 4 Articles
- Smart mobile phones 864 Articles
- Storm mobile phones 3 Articles
- Symbian mobile phones 78 Articles
- Tocco mobile phones 5 Articles
- Touchscreen phones 580 Articles
- Tough mobile phones 4 Articles
- Twitter mobile phones 13 Articles
- Upcoming mobile phones 827 Articles
- Viewty mobile phones 1 Articles
- Vivaz mobile phones 8 Articles
- Walkman mobile phones 6 Articles
- Watch phones 7 Articles
- White mobile phones 7 Articles
- Windows mobile phones 29 Articles
- World Cup mobile phones 11 Articles
- Xperia mobile phones 6 Articles
- XSeries mobile phones 3 Articles
-
Networks
-
Technology
Comments