We earn commissions from brands listed on this site, which influences how listings are presented.
Advertising Disclosure

Capital Shield Home Review 2024

Affordable & Local Home Warranty Plans
By Patrick SatherBy Patrick Sather -
Last Updated: Feb 01, 2023
logo-CAPITAL SHIELD HOME SERVICES
Visit Site
Average annual premium
$480-$960
Contractors
Local network of certified technicians
Service call fee
$75

Our Verdict

Capital Shield Home offers affordable home warranty coverage in six states. You can choose from one of its standard plans or customize your plan to suit your needs. 

Capital Shield Home contracts with local, certified technicians for all service visits. It provides a 90-day workmanship guarantee for parts and a 60-day guarantee for labor. It does not offer 24/7 phone support but does enable you to submit claims anytime through its website. 

Average annual premium
$480-$960
Contractors
Local network of certified technicians
Service call fee
$75

Capital Shield Home Services Pros & Cons

PROS

Affordable $75 copay per service visit
Virtual repairs and plans starting at $19
90-day workmanship guarantee for parts and 60 days for labor

CONS

Only available in MD, MS, OH, PA, NY, and NJ
No 24/7 phone support

How do I know I can trust this Capital Shield Home Services review?

Top10.com authors, contributors, and editors are serious about research. We combine our own experience with the services we recommend, with reviews that come from verified users–just like you! Together, with reviews from industry experts, we find the Top 10 best products and services to make sure you can choose with confidence and ease.

Capital Shield Home Services Capital Shield Home Services Visit Site

Capital Shield Home Plans 

Capital Shield Home offers three home warranty plans: Gold, Platinum, and Diamond. Its Diamond Plan is the most comprehensive and includes coverage for every appliance and system available through Capital Shield Home. If you want, you can add optional coverage for individual appliances or services not normally included in the Gold or Platinum plans. 

Here’s a list of the appliances and systems covered under each plan:


Gold Plan

Best for basic appliances, heating, and AC

Platinum Plan

Best for kitchen appliances, heating, and AC

Diamond Plan

Best for comprehensive coverage

Refrigerator

Water Dispenser

Range/Stove/Oven

Cooktop

Built-in Microwave

Dishwasher

Garbage Disposal

Washer

Dryer

Air Conditioning

Heating

Thermostat

Plumbing Stoppages

Plumbing Systems

Water Heater

Interior Electrical

Main Panel/Breaker

Ceiling fans

Garage Door Opener

Refrigerator Icemaker

X

Trash Compactor

X

Ice Maker

X

Spa Tub

X

Smoke Detectors

X

Bathroom Exhaust Fans

X

Attic Fans and Vents

X

X

Doorbells

X

X

Switches and Fixtures

X

X

Pool/Spa

X

X

Limited Roof Leak

X

X

Rekey

X

X

Code Violations, Permits, and Modifications

X

X

Free Air Filter

X

X

HVAC Maintenance

X

X

Faucets and Fixtures

X

X

Sump Pump

X

X

House Sewage Ejector

X

X

Central Vacuum

X

X


Optional add-ons

Capital Shield Home enables you to purchase optional coverage for appliances or services normally excluded from its Gold and Platinum plans. Rather than paying for its Diamond Plan, you can add any of the following options individually to your Gold or Platinum plan for a separate fee: 

  • Refrigerator Icemaker

  • Trash Compactor

  • Ice Maker

  • Spa Tub

  • Smoke Detectors

  • Bathroom Exhaust Fans

  • Attic Fans and Vents

  • Doorbells

  • Switches and Fixtures

  • Pool/Spa

  • Limited Roof Leak

  • Rekey

  • Code Violations, Permits, and Modifications

  • Free Air Filter

  • HVAC Maintenance

  • Faucets and Fixtures

  • Sump Pump

  • House Sewage Ejector

  • Central Vacuum


Plan exclusions

Except for limited roof leak protection, Capital Shield Home only covers internal appliances and systems. Roof leak protection comes standard with its Diamond Plan but may be individually added to its Gold or Platinum plans. 

Your Capital Shield Home warranty contract will provide you with the annual coverage limit for each appliance and system in your plan. Annual coverage limits can vary, so you’ll need to speak with an agent to get a quote. Your contract also includes information about the types of repairs excluded from coverage. 

Exclusions include damage caused by accidents, floods, fires, or other natural disasters, as well as routine maintenance, excluding HVAC maintenance with its Diamond Plan. 

Capital Shield Home Plan Pricing 

Compared to its competitors, Capital Shield Home’s pricing is remarkably affordable. In particular, I like that its Gold Plan includes basic appliance and systems coverage starting at just $40 per month. Many home warranty companies offer plans at that price, but typically these lower-cost plans cover either systems or appliances, not both. The Platinum Plan is also rather affordable at $50 per month, while the Diamond Plan is on the higher side at $80 per month. 

Plans

Price

Gold Plan

From $40/month

Platinum Plan

From $50/month

Diamond Plan

From $80/month


Unlike some companies, Capital Shield Home does not let you customize your service fee. Instead, it charges a flat $75 fee for all service visits. 

How to File a Claim with Capital Shield Home

You can file a claim online through Capital Shield Home’s website or over the phone with its customer service team. Capital Shield Home maintains a network of certified technicians within each state that it provides coverage. You can expect a service technician to visit your home within 48 hours of submitting your claim. 

At the time of your service visit, you’ll need to pay the $75 service fee to cover parts and labor. Capital Shield Home provides a 90-day workmanship guarantee for parts and a 60-day guarantee for labor. 

Is Capital Shield Home Legit? 

Capital Shield Home appears legit based on the information I gathered from its website and conversations with its customer service team. One thing is that it is not yet accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB). 

Although this is not necessarily a cause for alarm, make sure you do substantial research before you sign a contract with Capital Shield Home or any other home warranty provider.

What’s Unique about Capital Shield Home?

Capital Shield Home is unique in that it offers both appliance and systems coverage in its most affordable plan. Many home warranty companies offer plans priced similarly to Capital Shield Home’s Gold Plan, but most of these plans only cover appliances or systems, not both.

At this time, Capital Shield Home is offering an introductory offer to new customers. New customers can earn up to $150 off any plan. Additionally, if you choose its Gold or Platinum plan, you can get free limited roof coverage for one year.

Help and Support

You can contact Capital Shield Home’s customer service team by phone from 9am to 5pm, Monday-Friday. While it does not offer 24/7 phone support, you can submit a claim anytime through its website or call and leave a message outside business hours. Upon receiving your claim, Capital Shield Home will connect you with a service technician within 48 hours. 

Capital Shield Home features a limited FAQ page on its website, as well as articles about home maintenance. 

What about the Capital Shield Home App?

Presently, Capital Shield Home does not have an app.

How to Get Started with Capital Shield Home

To get started with Capital Shield Home, simply visit its website to request a quote or call its sales team during regular business hours. Once you submit your quote online, a member of Capital Shield Home’s sales team will call you either the same day or the following business day.

When you request a quote, you’ll need to provide your name, phone number, email address, ZIP code, and information about your home. Please note that Capital Shield Home only offers warranty coverage in six states at this time: Maryland, Mississippi, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York, and New Jersey.

How Capital Shield Home Compares to Other Home Warranty Services


Capital Shield Home
Choice Home Warranty
Select Home Warranty
American Home Shield

Average annual premium

$480-$960

$476-$660

$599.88-$839.88

$500-$700

Contractors

Local, in-network certified technicians

15,000 in-network contractors

6,800 in-network contractors

17,000 in-network contractors

Service call fee

$75

$75-$85

$75-$100

$75-$125

Service requests

Service requests can be made by phone from 9am to 5pm, Monday-Friday, or 24/7 online

Service requests can be submitted online or by phone, 24/7

Service requests can be submitted online or by phone, 24/7

Service requests can be submitted online or by phone, 24/7


Capital Shield Home vs Choice Home Warranty

Capital Shield Home features competitive pricing compared with Choice Home Warranty. Both offer affordable basic warranty options that cover your home’s major appliances and systems. Choice Home Warranty may charge more for service visits, as its fees can range from $75 to $85, while Capital Shield Home charges a flat fee of $75.

That said, Choice Home Warranty offers coverage in more states than Capital Shield Home. Additionally, unlike Capital Shield Home, Choice Home Warranty offers 24/7 phone support and has an established track record. 

Capital Shield Home vs Select Home Warranty

In terms of price, Capital Shield Home offers more affordable basic coverage than Select Home Warranty. Its Gold Plan covers your home's major appliances and systems, while Select Home Warranty’s comparably priced plans only cover either appliances or systems, not both. 

However, Select Home Warranty provides 24/7 phone support for claims, while Capital Shield Home does not. Moreover, Select Home Warranty offers coverage in states not currently supported by Capital Shield Home. 

Capital Shield Home Services Capital Shield Home Services Visit Site

Capital Shield Home vs American Home Shield

Capital Shield Home’s basic plans surpasses American Home Shield’s basic coverage options when it comes to affordability. Its Gold Plan covers your home’s major appliances and systems. Meanwhile, American Home Shield’s similarly priced plans cover either basic appliances or systems but not both.

American Home Shield beats Capital Shield Home when it comes to claims support. Unlike American Home Shield, Capital Shield Home does not offer 24/7 claims support over the phone. Additionally, American Home Shield works with a much larger network of certified technicians and offers coverage in more states. 

The Bottom Line

Capital Shield Home offers affordable appliances and systems home warranty coverage in six states. It enables you to customize your plan or choose from one of its three standard plans. It charges a flat fee of $75 for service visits, so you’ll always know what you can expect to pay for coverage.

Although it lacks 24/7 claims support over the phone, I appreciate that Capital Shield Home accepts claim requests through its website. Capital Shield Home only works with local, certified technicians and schedules service visits within 48 hours of receiving your claim. 

Frequently Asked Questions
When does Capital Shield Home coverage begin?+-

Your coverage with Capital Shield Home begins 30 days after enrolling in one of its warranty plans.

Can I purchase Capital Shield Home for a rental property?+-

Yes, a landlord may purchase a warranty through Capital Shield Home for a rental property. Coverage works the same for rental properties as for owner-occupied homes.

How much does Capital Shield Home cost?+-

Capital Shield Home charges a monthly or annual premium plus a $75 fee for each service visit from a certified technician. It offers a Gold Plan, Platinum Plan, and Diamond Plan, which start at $40, $50, and $80 per month, respectively.

Patrick Sather is an award-winning personal finance writer and licensed broker who has worked for some of the largest financial firms in the United States, including TD Ameritrade and Pacific Life. A graduate of the University of Nebraska in both Economics and International Trade and English, Sather writes for Top10.com sharing his insights on life's most common financial decisions.

Copyright © 2009 - 2024 Natural Intelligence Ltd. All Rights Reserved.

Mailing address:

4023 Kennett Pike #50055

Wilmington, DE 19807

Top10.com is designed to help users make confident decisions online, this website contains information about a wide range of products and services. Certain details, including but not limited to prices and special offers, are provided to us directly from our partners and are dynamic and subject to change at any time without prior notice. Though based on meticulous research, the information we share does not constitute legal or professional advice or forecast, and should not be treated as such.

Reproduction in whole or in part is strictly prohibited.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.